Skip to content

Compare

QuoteSooner vs. a spreadsheet for CNC quoting

What a spreadsheet does well

Most small CNC shops quote in Excel, and for good reason. A spreadsheet is free, it is already open, and it does exactly what its owner built it to do. The shop rate, the material markup and the setup formula are all yours, and nobody has to learn anything new.

If one experienced person quotes, the parts are simple, and a few requests come in each week, a spreadsheet is a perfectly good tool. Switching only makes sense when the spreadsheet starts costing you time or jobs.

Where spreadsheets start to cost you

The formula is rarely the problem. The work around it is:

  • Re-typing the drawing. Part number, revision, material, tolerances, finish and quantities are copied by hand from a PDF and an email into cells. A missed Rev C or a misread finish becomes a wrong price.
  • Nothing records what was checked. The sheet holds the answer, not the questions. Whether someone confirmed the material, or noticed the email asked for a different revision than the drawing, lives in someone’s head.
  • Last time’s price is hard to find. When a part comes back, finding what you charged means searching folders named BR-4471_quote_v3_FINAL.xlsx and old emails.
  • The quote is a second document. The numbers are in Excel and the customer’s quote is in Word or a PDF template, so every change is made twice.
  • Requests wait. When the person who knows the spreadsheet is on the floor, the inbox waits too, and the buyer has often sent the same request to other shops.

Side by side

A spreadsheet compared with QuoteSooner for quoting CNC work
ComparedSpreadsheetQuoteSooner
Starting pointA blank sheet or a copied old quoteThe customer’s drawings and request, uploaded
Part detailsTyped by hand from the PDF and emailRead from the drawing and request, each with the page and words it came from; you confirm them
Missing or conflicting detailsWhatever the estimator noticesChecks that must be resolved before the quote can be sent
Your rates and formulasFully yours, in your own formulasYour shop rates; enter a unit price directly or build it from material, setup and run time
Quantity breaksExtra columns, copied per jobEach quantity priced side by side, with setup spread across it
One-time chargesA line you remember to addTooling, first-article and other one-time charges on their own lines
Past pricesSearch old files and emailsShown on the part when you quoted it before
The quote the buyer getsA separate Word or PDF template, attached to an emailA branded quote from the same numbers, with a page where the buyer can accept it with a PO number; on Shop, sent from your own Gmail or Outlook
CostFree with OfficeFree for 5 production RFQs a month; Shop US$249 a month per shop
QuoteSooner prices as published on quotesooner.com/pricing on October 2, 2026.

What changes with QuoteSooner

You upload the customer’s drawings and paste their request. QuoteSooner reads the part details, and anything it is unsure of, or anything the drawing and the email disagree on, becomes a check you confirm or correct. It never fills a gap with a guess.

BR-4471 Rev C: the finish, read as Hard anodize Type III Class 2, highlighted where it is marked on page 1 of the drawing.BR-4471 Rev C: the finish, read as Hard anodize Type III Class 2, highlighted where it is marked on page 1 of the drawing.
Part BR-4471 Rev C: every value read from the drawing shows where it was marked.

Then you price it the way you already do. Type the unit price for each quantity, or build it from material, setup and run time at your own rates. If you quoted the same part before, that price is shown beside it. When you approve the price, the quote goes out (from your own Gmail or Outlook on the Shop plan), and the buyer can accept it online with a PO number or decline. Won and lost quotes are recorded with a reason, so the next quote starts from what happened to the last one.

When to stay with a spreadsheet

  • You quote fewer than a handful of requests a week and they are simple.
  • One person quotes everything and never needs to hand a quote to someone else.
  • Your requests rarely include drawings, so there is little to read or check.
  • The monthly price would cost more than the time it saves you.

If that describes your shop, keep the spreadsheet. If requests are waiting on one person, or a misread drawing has cost you money, a free account and one of your own requests will show quickly whether QuoteSooner is worth it.

Questions

Can I keep my own pricing formulas?
Your rates, yes. In QuoteSooner you can type the unit price for each quantity directly, so a shop that prices in its head or in its own spreadsheet can keep doing that while the drawing, checks and quote stay together. You can also build a price from material and operations at your own rates.
Do I need a CAD model?
No. You can quote from PDF drawings and the customer’s requirements. When a model comes with the RFQ, STEP, IGES, STL and 3MF files open in 3D beside the drawing, where you can measure distances; on STEP and IGES, holes, pockets and setups are recognised.
Does QuoteSooner guess prices for me?
No. It reads the part details for you to confirm and shows what you charged for the same part before. With a model attached it can suggest a starting price from your own rates, marked as an estimate. It learns from your sent quotes, and by default fills in only once it has come within 30% of five of them. The price on the quote is always one you entered or approved.
What does it cost compared to Excel?
QuoteSooner is free for 5 production RFQs a month for one user. The Shop plan is US$249 a month per shop with no seat or quote limits; until February 5, 2027, a new monthly subscription is US$199 a month for its first 3 months. Excel costs nothing extra if you already have Office, so the comparison is the time spent re-typing, checking and searching, and the jobs lost to slow quotes.

See it on your own drawings.